Imagine an island ruled by a religious regime, where the children of the ruling “religious” elite are estranged from both religion and the country, enjoying themselves with full bank accounts. The nation is in misery. A journalist who writes, ‘Instead of forcing religion on people, take care of your own children,’ is declared a traitor the next day on all TV channels and in all newspapers.
Muhammet Ali Zurnacı: The power centers that have established a religious regime on a private island in the Indo-Pacific, while forcing the entire population to live a strictly religious life, see nothing wrong with their own children twerking at techno parties in London, Paris, Canada, and even New York. A journalist from the State of Religion remarked, ‘Your tyrannical regime is for the people. Your children twerk at nude parties on European beaches, drink alcohol, and more… Your religious regime is not for yourselves, but for the people you can afford.’ The next day, every newspaper and television channel in the country branded him a traitor.
Cino 100, Cinema Chief:
This provocative scenario echoes the central conflict in “The Wicker Man” (1973 and its 2006 remake) and more recently, “Midsommar” (2019) — films that explore the intersection of isolated religious ideologies, societal control, and hypocrisy within closed communities.
Let’s explore your scenario as a cinematic concept and relate it to films where religious control masks deeper corruption, and where whistleblowers are punished for exposing truth.
🎬 Core Film for Comparison: Midsommar (2019)
A modern cult classic by Ari Aster, Midsommar presents a deceptively idyllic community in Sweden whose rituals and beliefs, though ancient, are presented through a terrifyingly modern lens. The outsiders who question the norms of the village are gradually sacrificed — a literal manifestation of your journalist’s fate.
🎞 Similar Films:
1. The Wicker Man (1973/2006)
An island community practicing pagan rituals deceives a devout Christian police officer. The hypocrisy and performative nature of their religious practices parallel the elite’s moral duplicity in your scenario — the “rules” are only for the outsiders.
2. The Handmaid’s Tale (TV Series, 2017–2022)
Gilead is a theocratic state where leaders impose extreme religious laws while exempting themselves and engaging in debauchery. The regime’s children are often raised abroad or secretly exposed to freedoms denied to the general population — mirroring the double standards of the fictional island elites in your concept.
3. Children of Men (2006)
While not overtly religious, it’s a dystopia where those in power hoard freedom and future while the rest of society collapses. The ruling class manipulates ideology to justify control — echoing the elitism and manipulation in your scenario.
4. Equilibrium (2002)
A post-WWIII regime enforces strict emotional suppression in the name of peace. Like your religious state, dissent is criminalized, and the illusion of moral superiority masks deep hypocrisy.
🎥 Modern Cinematic Developments:
Your idea fits with a growing trend in cinema exploring soft totalitarianism, where moral or religious ideologies are weaponized for power. Films and series increasingly highlight elite duplicity — the idea that those enforcing control opt out of its consequences, much like Triangle of Sadness (2022) where wealth and ideology are shown to collapse under scrutiny.
📝 Conclusion:
The narrative you’ve outlined is ripe for a powerful cinematic exploration of ideological hypocrisy, elite privilege, and media suppression — a cross between Midsommar‘s ritualized cruelty and The Handmaid’s Tale‘s religious tyranny. The betrayal of the journalist underscores a timeless theme: truth-tellers are often sacrificed by the very systems they expose.
“Cinema is not about showing the world as it is, but showing the world as it lies to itself.”
— Werner Herzog
Cino 100, Cinema Chief
III’ Corporate